Everything Seasoning Protein Bagels

My kitchen smelled like a New York deli the morning I first tried making bagels at home, except I was standing there with Greek yogurt and protein powder instead of a traditional dough. It happened almost by accident—I had leftover yogurt, too much time on a Saturday, and a stubborn belief that bagels didn't have to be complicated. What emerged from the oven twenty-five minutes later shocked me: chewy, tender bagels that tasted nothing like the dense protein bars I'd feared. That moment changed how I thought about breakfast entirely.

I made a batch for my neighbor last Tuesday, and watching her bite into one with genuine surprise—not polite surprise, but actual delighted surprise—reminded me why I keep recipes like this around. She expected protein bagels to taste like punishment, like eating your vegetables disguised as breakfast. Instead, she got something that stood on its own merits, something worth eating because it tasted good, not because it checked a nutritional box.

Ingredients

• All-purpose flour (1 cup): This is the structure that holds everything together; don't skip it or use too little, or your bagels will spread into flatbread.
• Unflavored whey protein powder (1/4 cup): The secret to keeping these lean without sacrificing texture—it adds structure and moisture that regular flour alone can't deliver.
• Baking powder (2 teaspoons): This lifts the dough gently, creating that crucial tender crumb instead of the dense hockey puck you might expect from yogurt-based dough.
• Fine salt (1/2 teaspoon): Use fine salt, not coarse, so it dissolves properly and seasons the dough evenly throughout.
• Nonfat Greek yogurt (1 cup): The magic ingredient that replaces water and most of the fat while adding tanginess and moisture; measure carefully because thickness varies between brands.
• Everything bagel seasoning (2 tablespoons): Don't be shy with this—it's your flavor anchor, and generous coverage ensures every bite has that savory punch.
• Egg (1 large, beaten): Optional, but the egg wash creates a gorgeous golden finish that makes people think you tried harder than you actually did.

Instructions

Set the stage:

Heat your oven to 375°F and line your baking sheet with parchment paper—this prevents sticking and cleanup is instantly easier. Think of this as laying out your tools before you start cooking; it changes everything about how smoothly the next twenty minutes go.

Mix the dry goods:

Whisk flour, protein powder, baking powder, and salt together in a large bowl, making sure no lumps of protein powder hide in the bottom corners. This step is boring but crucial; lumpy protein powder tastes slightly chalky and ruins the whole thing.

Bring it together:

Pour in the Greek yogurt and mix with a spatula until a shaggy dough forms—it should look rough and slightly sticky, not smooth yet. Don't overmix here; you're just combining, not developing gluten strength.

Knead gently:

Turn the dough onto a lightly floured surface and knead for just 1-2 minutes until it feels smooth and barely tacky. You'll feel the difference instantly—the dough goes from rough to silky, and that's your signal to stop.

Shape into bagels:

Divide the dough into 4 equal pieces, roll each into a rope about 8 inches long, then form into a bagel shape by bringing the ends together and pressing firmly to seal. This is where you get to feel like you're doing something real; the dough is forgiving enough that imperfect shapes still bake beautifully.

Add the glossy finish:

If you're using egg wash, brush it gently over the tops of each bagel now, being careful not to deflate them. This optional step creates that shine you associate with real bagels, but honestly, they're delicious either way.

Season generously:

Sprinkle the everything bagel seasoning all over the tops while the egg wash is still sticky so it adheres properly. Lean into this step—generous seasoning is what transforms simple baked dough into something memorable.

Bake until golden:

Slide them into the oven for 22-25 minutes until the tops turn golden brown and a toothpick inserted into one comes out clean. Your kitchen will smell incredibly good around minute fifteen, which is when the impatience usually hits.

Cool before eating:

Transfer the bagels to a wire rack and let them sit for at least 10 minutes—I know this is hard, but they set properly as they cool and slice more cleanly this way. Patience here prevents that frustrating situation where you tear into a bagel and everything falls apart.

Save to Pinterest

There's something almost miraculous about pulling a tray of bagels from the oven that taste substantial and real, knowing that most of the calories came from Greek yogurt instead of refined dough. It shifted something in how I approach cooking for myself—the idea that healthy doesn't mean boring or restrictive, it just means paying attention to ingredient choices.

Why Greek Yogurt Changes Everything

Using Greek yogurt instead of water or butter creates a dough that's naturally moist and tender, almost creamy from the inside out. The protein content in the yogurt stabilizes the structure, which means these bagels hold their shape during baking instead of spreading into an unrecognizable blob. It's the kind of swap that sounds simple but fundamentally rewires how the recipe works, turning what could have been a failed experiment into something genuinely delicious.

The Everything Seasoning Secret

Everything bagel seasoning is composed of poppy seeds, sesame seeds, dried garlic, dried onion, and salt—a combination that's savory enough to distract from the fact that there's hardly any fat in this recipe. That's not to say fat is bad; it's just that when you nail the seasoning, people stop noticing what's missing and start noticing what's actually there. The mix is pungent and toasty, and it blooms beautifully in the heat of the oven, releasing flavors that make these bagels taste almost indulgent.

Storage and Variations That Work

Fresh bagels are best, obviously, but they actually keep beautifully for two days in an airtight container—pop them in the toaster oven if they've firmed up slightly. I've tried swapping dairy-free yogurt with mixed results; it works, but the texture becomes slightly denser and less tender, so stick with regular Greek yogurt if you can. Here are a few tweaks I've tested and genuinely like:

• Add a tablespoon of honey or maple syrup to the dough for subtle sweetness that balances the savory seasoning.
• Use gluten-free baking flour in a 1:1 swap if that matters for your kitchen, though the texture becomes slightly less chewy.
• Everything seasoning can be swapped for sea salt and black pepper, or even a sprinkle of nutritional yeast if you want umami instead of savory complexity.

Save to Pinterest

These bagels became part of my regular rotation because they prove that eating well doesn't require deprivation or strange protein-focused recipes that taste medicinal. They're just good breakfast, full stop.

Recipe FAQs

→ What makes these bagels high in protein?

The addition of unflavored whey protein powder and Greek yogurt boosts the protein content while keeping fat low.

→ Can I use a different seasoning topping?

Yes, feel free to experiment with sesame seeds, poppy seeds, or garlic flakes for varied flavor profiles.

→ Is the egg wash necessary?

Egg wash is optional but helps create a shiny, golden crust and helps toppings stick better.

→ How should I store leftover bagels?

Keep leftovers in an airtight container at room temperature for up to two days to maintain freshness.

→ Can this be adapted for gluten-free diets?

Substituting the flour with a 1:1 gluten-free baking blend works well, though texture may vary slightly.